"It makes me a little sad not to give this hotel 5 stars because it has so much potential to be incredible. Starting with the positives… The location is fantastic – only around a 15–20 minute drive from Palma. We hired a car, so I can’t comment on taxi prices, but there is plenty of free parking. The photos do this hotel a disservice. They really need updating because the hotel is much nicer in person. Our room was lovely, with comfortable bedding, and nice quality towels. The bathroom was slightly dated, but nothing that affected our stay. The gym was another pleasant surprise. It’s better than the photos suggest. I also had a few personal training sessions with Miguel, and they were excellent. He was knowledgeable, motivating, and I’d highly recommend booking a session if you’re staying here. The food exceeded expectations (except the pasta dishes). Breakfast was also good, with a nice selection of food. We often went towards the end of the breakfast service, and I was really impressed that everything was still fully stocked and being replenished. So many hotels start packing away early or stop replacing items before breakfast officially ends, which is always disappointing. Here, it was clear they maintained the same standard right until the end of service. A special mention to the chef making the eggs every morning—he was always smiling, friendly, and a lovely way to start the day. The grounds were very well kept. The things that stopped this being a true 5-star experience… Firstly, the spa massage was genuinely one of the worst I’ve ever had. I won’t go into detail because the reception team handled the situation professionally and compensated me appropriately, so they are already aware of the issue. Truly horrendous. Communication from the hotel could also have been better. During our stay there was a wedding taking place, as well as renovations to one of the bars. Neither of these ruined our stay, but it would have been appreciated to have been informed before we arrived. It’s about managing expectations, and I’d expect that level of transparency from a hotel of this standard. A big disappointment was the pool service. The actual pool itself is beautiful (other than the really ugly bins next to the pool boys), and the sunbeds are incredibly comfortable, and everything is clean and well maintained. However, ordering drinks was frustratingly difficult. Staff were very hard to find, I often had to chase someone down just to place an order, and on a couple of occasions my drinks were simply forgotten. It’s such a shame because I would have happily spent much more on food and drinks if the service had been more attentive. Most of the time there seemed to be only one person covering the entire pool area, which simply wasn’t enough. The only good service by the pool was the little complimentary treats they brought around during the day, like fresh fruit and appetisers—a thoughtful touch. The pool boys were also quite inconsistent. Sometimes they would come over with towels, other times they wouldn’t. At other luxury hotels I’ve stayed at, someone greets you as you arrive, prepares your sunbed, and brings fresh towels without you needing to ask. Here, that level of service was very hit and miss. The contrast between the breakfast service—which was warm and attentive and the pool service was striking. It felt like two completely different standards of hospitality. Despite these issues, we really enjoyed our stay and absolutely plan to return. This hotel has all the ingredients to be a true 5-star destination, and with a few improvements to communication, spa and pool service, it really could be exceptional."

"The hotel owner held a private party tonight. Our room, 751, overlooks the terrace where the event took place. The noise level was deafening, making sleep impossible, and our room has no double glazing to block it out. When I first contacted reception, I was assured the party would finish by 23:00. It continued until at least 23:30. On my second call, the staff member was extremely unprofessional and rude, stating only that it was the owner’s event and nothing could be done — before ending the call abruptly. Subsequent calls went unanswered. When I went down to the front desk personally, the same staff member was dismissive and hostile. He ignored me completely and retreated to the back area. When I began recording for evidence, he threatened to call the police. We have been loyal guests at this hotel for twelve years running. This experience has been completely unacceptable, and we will not be returning. There are many hotels across Mallorca that value their guests and uphold proper service standards."

"Hotel very nice, pool great, food poor. Had pool meals and restaurent meals and they were overpriced and very ordinary."

"Visited at a quiet time in April….. can’t fault the hotel, genuinely beautiful, stunning art everywhere you look, views out to the sea and the city of Palma are a pleasant backdrop. Gym great, we don’t use the spa but looked nice. Breakfast as good as any hotel didn’t use the restaurant but ate at the roof terrace once, no complaints! As with most high end hotels, it’s the level of attention from the staff which sets it apart… every interaction was pleasant… the manager arranged a cocktail evening to meet the guests which was a lovely touch.. The morning yoga was a refreshing start to the day and the instructor was excellent Old world charm, beautiful decor and both our room and the pool area were a pleasure to enjoy. Thankyou hotel Castillo Son Vida for such a lovely visit."