1/5

Montauk Yacht Club

Name: Montauk Yacht Club
Address: 32 Star Island Rd, Montauk, NY 11954, The Hamptons, United States
Rating: 4.7

5% cash back when you book with PressBeyond

Montauk Yacht Club

The Hamptons • Montauk • OPTIMIZE

avg. $212 / night

Includes $11 / night in cash back

Cash back is redeemable via Virtual Visa, Venmo, or bank transfer starting 24-48 hours after check-out

Exclusive PressBeyond Benefits

Get to where you see yourself

Ultra-clean, global, hand-picked hotel curation & imagery designed to help you visualize enticing environments and the elevated social experiences they create

Cash back

5% cash back on all completed stays (redeemable via Virtual Visa, Venmo, or bank transfer starting 24-48 hours after check-out)

Credit card points

Credit and debit card charges are processed directly by the hotel (i.e. not PressBeyond), meaning that any travel-specific credit card points or incentives that you normally get as a cardholder for direct hotel bookings are preserved

Hotel loyalty points

Points accrual and status eligibility with major hotel loyalty programs: Marriott Bonvoy, Hilton Honors, World of Hyatt, and others

Free breakfast

Breakfast-included rate options available

Room upgrades

Complimentary room upgrades (subject to property availability)

Extend your stay

Early check-in and late check-out (subject to property availability)

Location

Loading map...

PB hotel design editorial

Carl Fisher built his private social club on Star Island in 1928, the same restless developer who had dredged Miami Beach from mangrove swamp and dreamed of doing the same to Montauk. Nearly a century later, the Montauk Yacht Club returned to life on Memorial Day Weekend 2023 following a multi-million dollar renovation by Safe Harbor Marinas, its 35 acres on Lake Montauk restored to something closer to Fisher's original vision of coastal leisure at scale — 107 rooms, three pools, and the Hamptons' largest marina with more than 200 wet slips stretching into the harbor. The white lighthouse tower that anchors the compound remains the property's most recognizable landmark, visible from the aerial view as a kind of compass point between the pool terrace and the docks packed with superyachts. Newport-based KPR Interiors shaped the renovation around what they called quiet, elevated leisure, and the rooms deliver exactly that register — whitewashed shiplap walls paired with charcoal upholstered headboards and bleached oak frames in some configurations, linen curtains and Adirondack chairs on private decks in the waterfront cottages dating to the original 1928 construction. The outdoor terrace dining space leans into teak furniture with rope-woven backs and rattan lounge pieces arranged beneath a louvered pergola, the marina's forest of masts providing the only backdrop needed. Nothing here strains for effect; the setting has always done the heavy lifting.

Travel notes

No travel notes provided yet.

About

No description provided yet.

Amenities

Pool

Internet

Kids Activities

Beachfront

Shuttle Bus Service

Suites

Room service

Free Internet

Free Parking

Wheelchair Access

Montauk Yacht Club Reviews

87 reviews

"Amazing place, Amazing food and Amazing sceneries"

A Tripadvisor traveler review

Apr 19, 2026

"From the moment we arrived at Montauk Yacht Club, the atmosphere enveloped us in a quiet, refined calm that set the tone for the entire stay. We spent four wonderful nights, Wednesday through Sunday, and every day reinforced why this property stands in a class of its own along the East End. The accommodations were quite eloquent. The rooms were spacious, beautifully appointed, and carried that signature coastal elegance that blends barefoot ease with genuine luxury. Waking up each morning to the serene waterfront views of Lake Montauk felt deeply relaxing. The staff were warm, attentive, and professional and made every interaction feel personal and genuine. From the front desk, room service, to dining, the team ensured every comfort was met. The grounds themselves are quite exquisite with 16 acres of lush waterfront expanse harboring a private beach, indoor and outdoor pools, and a marina that frames the property in an almost cinematic way. It’s the kind of place that invites you to slow down, breathe, and simply be present. Montauk Yacht Club is a destination for those seeking an upscale, peaceful, and deeply enjoyable coastal retreat."

A Tripadvisor traveler review

Apr 14, 2026

"We had a perfect vacation at the Montauk Yacht Club with friends. The hotel, lobby and restaurant are beautiful. The view of the water from the rooms is spectacular. Every meal we had was delicious. Every staff member I encountered was very helpful. I can not say enough good things about this resort."

A Tripadvisor traveler review

Apr 14, 2026

"The Montauk Yacht Club was amazing Great place ..The staff was friendly and knowledgeable. Our view and room was great. I would recommend staying here all the time in Montauk"

A Tripadvisor traveler review

Apr 12, 2026

"Gorgeous property. Even though we were there at season opening, all of the staff were perky, attentive and friendly, and quick to address our needs. We started in partial view, which had a very nice view overlooking the fire pit and lighthouse, but we requested a move to avoid the cute but noisy kids next door. The full on water view was awesome. Delicious food and excellent bar service."

A Tripadvisor traveler review

Apr 08, 2026

Guest photos

+48